Real VoicesReal Voices

The Sinister Reality Behind Karma and Reincarnation Beliefs — Michael Heiser

John 14:6

John 14:6

apologetics

January 30, 2026
Reincarnation—the belief in a soul's transmigration through successive bodies after death—is controversial and largely rejected by scientists and scholars, though popularized in culture; some defend it biblically via John 9:1-4, where disciples ask if a blind man's sin or his parents' caused his condition, implying pre-birth sin that Jesus allegedly doesn't refute, but this fails logically (no prior life or transmigration mentioned, only possible soul pre-existence) and grammatically (Greek disjunctive negative in v.3—"neither this man sinned nor his parents, but..."—emphatically denies pre-birth sin). Other proofs like Herod/Matt 14/Lk 9 mistaking Jesus for risen John the Baptist (impossible as contemporaries) or Elijah (never died, per 2 Kings 2; Mal 4:5 fulfilled in John's "spirit and power," Lk 1:17) reflect Jewish misconceptions, not endorsement. Karma, intertwined as Hinduism's moral debt repaid via reincarnations (samsara) through suffering equivalent to past wrongs—e.g., greed leading to future poverty, chosen pre-birth—promotes sinister complacency (e.g., ignoring castes/poor as they "work off karma"), contrasting Christianity's completed atonement (Col 2:14; 1 Pet 2:24; "It is finished"). Westernised "what goes around comes around" dilutes this into false consequence theology (misreading Num 32:23 or Gal 6:7), undermining grace, fostering bondage over cross-paid freedom, and revealing biblical illiteracy even among believers. #reincarnation #karma #StevenBancarz #Samsara #John9 #GreekGrammar #michaelheiser Link to original video: https://youtu.be/nfa0HxCfUnM?si=xtJX1GBAEKeDOqno Link to original video: https://youtu.be/7ioLQ3x07is?si=ByVuy7LHOjSqG0XU

Scripture

JohnJohn 9John 9:1John 9:1-4MatthewLuke2 Kings2 Kings 2MalachiMalachi 4:5Luke 1:17ColossiansColossians 2:141 Peter1 Peter 2:24NumbersNumbers 32Numbers 32:23GalatiansGalatians 6:7