The Strongest Argument Against Abortion (It’s Not Religious)
Small Town Bible Questions
teaching
January 10, 2026
Is there a non-religious, philosophical case against abortion?
In this video, I present what I believe is the strongest argument against abortion one grounded not in theology or emotion, but in reason, metaphysics, and human equality.
We examine the abortion debate through biology, moral philosophy, and personal identity, engaging directly with some of the most influential pro choice philosophers, including Michael Tooley, Peter Singer, Mary Anne Warren, Derek Parfit, Jeff McMahan, and Judith Jarvis Thomson.
Rather than arguing from religious premises, this video defends the ontological account of human dignity the view that every human being has intrinsic value simply by virtue of what they are, not what they can currently do.
If moral worth depends on consciousness, function, or awareness, then equality collapses. This video explains why.
⏱️ Chapters / Timestamps
00:00 – Intro
01:13 – What to Expect
02:27 – The Positive Case for Human Dignity
13:19 – Michael Tooley’s Argument
17:17 – Peter Singer’s View
23:22 – Mary Anne Warren on Personhood
29:25 – Parfit & McMahan: Psychological Continuity
35:34 – The Consequences of Rejecting the Ontological Account
39:12 – Judith Jarvis Thomson & Bodily Autonomy
46:49 – Contraception & IVF
52:52 – Conclusion
55:52 – Outro
📲 Follow Me on other platforms
📘 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/smalltownbiblequestions?mibextid=nwBsNb
📸 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/smalltownbiblequestions?igsh=MXJqYzIxeGFhZmY0aQ%3D%3D&utm_source=qr
🎵 TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@smalltownbiblequestions?_r=1&_d=e9521c633hbfam&sec_uid=MS4wLjABAAAAYKBhbAj0zvY6iUFv3DDDNe1ljpbfcCk6neEqFLRGIkAkmcc6tLCvxzEI2J5IIjLO&share_author_id=7201236061190702122&sharer_language=en&source=h5_m&u_code=e6dkd9kh2521jb&ug_btm=b8727,b0&social_share_type=4&utm_source=copy&sec_user_id=MS4wLjABAAAAYKBhbAj0zvY6iUFv3DDDNe1ljpbfcCk6neEqFLRGIkAkmcc6tLCvxzEI2J5IIjLO&tt_from=copy&utm_medium=ios&utm_campaign=client_share&enable_checksum=1&user_id=7201236061190702122&share_link_id=C7DE3E1F-5036-4B3D-8908-F11550FCB8CA&share_app_id=1233













