Can You Be a Jewish Catholic? With Dr. Costley and Dr. D’Costa
Ignatius Press
teaching
November 3, 2025
Jews are God’s Chosen People, and it is through God’s gratuitous gift of grace that the rest of the world (the Gentiles) are grafted onto the tree of salvation.
Get “From Sinai to Rome” Here: https://ignatius.com/from-sinai-to-rome-fstrp/?searchid=0&search_query=from+sinai+to+rome
Pope Pius XI once remarked, “Spiritually, we [Catholics] are all Semites,” and, as Saint Paul writes in the Romans, in a sense, Christians are Jews by adoption. In today’s episode, Andrew Petiprin is joined by Professors Angela Costley and Gavin D’Costa examines the question of Jewish–Catholic relations from every angle. They not only discuss how the Church is uniquely opposed to antisemitism, but also how the Church is deeply rooted in the Judaism. Finally, they discuss the reality of Hebrew Catholics and their role in the Body of Christ.
For more about Hebrew Catholics click here: https://www.hebrewcatholic.net/
SUBSCRIBE to our channel and never miss an episode of the Ignatius Press Podcast.
You can also listen to the podcast on Apple, Spotify, and other podcast platforms.
Follow us on social media:
Twitter/X: https://twitter.com/IgnatiusPress
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/ignatiuspress
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ignatius_press/
Music from Pexels, Gregor Quendel. https://www.classicals.de/legal
0:00 Hebrew Catholics, Jewish Roots, and New Book “From Sinai to Rome: Jewish Identity in the Catholic Church”
10:27 Nostra Aetate and Confronting Anti-Semitism
14:40 Fulfilling of the Jewish Prophecies
19:10 The Catholic Church Inserted into Israel
25:52 Gentile Engagement with Jewish Traditions
34:55 Exploring Essays in the Book
44:48 Evangelization and Jewish Identity
50:41 Hopes for the Book and Final Thoughts
Topics
hewbrew catholicsjewsjudaismcatholichebrewfrom sinai to romeangela costleygavin d'costaignatius press






















